James Hurst's "The Scarlet Ibis" demonstrates so powerfully that even where
there is unconditional love, there is also that little bit of malice, hidden, but
bound to show itself. In this story, it is obvious that the narrator truly loves his
brother Doodle for "(the narrator drags) him across the burning cotton field to
share with him the only beauty (the narrator) knew, Old Woman Swamp" (103).
Together, the two boys create a dynamic duo: the elder constantly making new
plans and games, the younger always following along. The love between them is
so strong and so tangible. The narrator does so much for Doodle, teaching him
activities that come naturally to normal children, taking him to Old Woman
Swamp and just about everywhere else, but most importantly of all, the narrator
instills in Doodle a sense of self-confidence and pride. Doodle, though, may have
done even more for the narrator in a subconscious way. By the suffering Doodle
has to go through, the narrator learns the value of hard work, the consequences
of pride, and the true meaning of blind love. All people have the ability to love,
but they also have the capability to hate. Even with the unbreakable bond the
two brothers share, the narrator realizes that "there is within (him) (and with
sadness (he) has watched it in others) a knot of cruelty borne by the stream of
love, much as our blood sometimes bears the seed of our destruction" (103).
The narrator is mean to Doodle sometimes, making Doodle touch his own coffin,
flipping him over in his go-cart, pushing him beyond his physical limit, and
ultimately, causing Doodle's untimely death. Where does this malevolence
come from? How can the narrator be so cruel to one he loves? The answer is
a combination of aspects. Pride, a huge culprit, motivates the narrator to teach
Doodle to walk in the first place, f...