inferior/superior dichotomy

Length: 3 Pages 795 Words

The Inferior/Superior Dichotomy Ebonics, which comes from the words “ebony” and “phonics” is a term that Linguistics use to describe Black Dialect or Black English. The debate over Ebonics has several sides. Almost everyone has an opinion. Rachel Jones and Sonja Lanehart are two authors who stand on opposing sides of this argument. In her article, “What’s Wrong with Black English,” Jones defends the mainstream language ideology while Lanehart defends the alternative language ideology in her article “African American Vernacular English, Identity, and Education.” Their views differ completely and not much common ground is shared between the two. In her article, Rachel Jones examines what it means and how it feels to be told she “sounds white” because she uses standard English. She notes that “for many blacks, standard English is not only unfamiliar, it is socially unacceptable.” Of Malcolm X, Martin Luther King, Jr., Toni Morrison, Alice Walker and James Baldwin she writes, “They all have full command of standard English, and I don’t think that knowledge takes away from their blackness or commitment to black people.” She concludes, “ Continue...

More sample essays on inferior/superior dichotomy

    The Idea of the Muse in Hesiod and Homer
    .... the first kicks of an embryonic dichotomy which has .... the Gods, and the Christians are irrevocably inferior to them. .... The Gods are superior to humans in both cases .... (1027 4 )

    Era of Inequality
    .... female identity and the femme fatale dichotomy contained therein .... had a whore (or at least an inferior woman) whom .... men in the novel to feel superior, in control .... (2232 9 )

    Themes in Jane Eyre
    .... conflicting elements or a judgment upon their dichotomy, or both. .... tends to classify individuals as either stronger (superior) or weaker (inferior) than she .... (2254 9 )

I think Jones feels this divided sense of self because she tries to keep an allegiance to the valued world of her family, but also looks at herself and her world through the eyes of the dominant culture. Sonja Lanehart discusses the dynamics of ideology and identity in regards to AAVE in her article. In her article, Jones comments on the fact that she is "almost Jekyll and Hyde-ish the way she can slip out of academic abstractions into a long, lean, double-negative-filled dialogue. In fact she states that "the ideology of SE is really not the ideology: it is hegemonism rooted in fear that is based on racial, ethnic...difference. nonstandard or the question of a separate language is not about language, but is about a community of speakers with a recognizable culture. She thinks that the ideology of progress is related to ethnocentrism, suggesting positive outcomes are race and culture related, rather than due to the failure of the education system. By her statements it is apparent that AAVE is innate for her as well, but she changes who she is to appease those around her. Jones seems to have more of a "double consciousness, as defined by W. She believes that a line can be drawn from protecting one's heritage and assimilating sufficiently to gain admittance to a society, but she believes that one can both assimilate and preserve and I cannot agree with that statement. My goal one day see more black people less dependent on a dialect that excludes them from full participation in the world we live in. As stated earlier, Jones admits to using AAVE at home where she is comfortable but changing herself for society. Jones insists that her use of standard English has propelled her from a life of poverty, and it seems that she believes that the use of Ebonics by people today is equivalent to succumbing to a form of self-delusion that rejects success as a "white thing. The two authors have two opposing arguments and do not share much common ground. She concludes that the debate over standard vs.


BRIEF PSYCHOTHERAPY Introduction Messer's tex
in this case responds to object relational dichotomy. superior, one time-unlimited was superior, and three that brief therapy was inferior at posttreatment at (1763 7 )

Thomas Mann Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man
war in which Germans are protecting their superior culture from the inferior democracies now the context of his argument this is something of a dichotomy. (1602 6 )

There is no dichotomy of the sexes as there is in the Western philosophies. In Taoism, there is no such thing as a superior or inferior sex. (1673 7 )

Critiques of Social Theories
of "the idea of a sexual dichotomy and the rearing, according to Weber, they are also inferior by nature Men have "superior strength and practical knowledge and (2025 8 )

Friendship in Two Novels
that should one depend on Schopenhauer's dichotomy for any men which reveal both Jim's superior wisdom and Far from demonstrating Jim's inferior knowledge, the (2234 9 )

US Government and the Plains Indian
were seen to be morally superior but intellectually and physically inferior: "a husband famously complain about the dichotomy between laundresses (6090 24 )