The Tempest - Shakespeare; Analysis of Caliban
Caliban, "a thing most brutish" whose name is a near anagram of 'cannibal', is implied by Prospero to be most primitive and inferior from a "vile race". Residing on the island of his birth he is enslaved by Prospero, the exiled duke of Milan, a powerful magician. Caliban is arguably a personification of the debate over colonialism and the conflict between cultures. As such, Caliban has been interpreted in various ways and in turn varied styles, affecting critical thoughts and the effectiveness with which Shakespeare's narrative is expressed.In Peter Greenaway's unique 1991 film entitled 'Prospero's Books', Caliban lives in a pit, a dank pool, which Greenway based on the hippopotamus pools in Victorian zoos. It is an unwholesome place with algae on the walls and an island-refuge with clumps of wretched grass and weeds. Caliban eventually appears out of the murky water moving rhythmically on the island suggestive of a primordial Caliban, yet one may interpret this Caliban as a higher being, his movements are like those of a spirit, reminiscent of the potentially noble creature of Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree's 1904 production. Greenaway, trained as a painter which influences his inventive style; he considers himself "primarily a pain
In contrast, Trinculo's appears as a jester in Messina's production, before hiding with Caliban under his cloak, the advantage of the literal translation is, although simple, achieves the comedy intended; an Italian speaking of the English who "will not give a doit to relieve a lame beggar", presents great social satire, criticising the English's 'tight-pockets'. The red plague rid you!" Messina presented these fierce emotions very literally but Jarman's version was more effective through better character interaction, the evident mutual detest of Prospero/Miranda and the native. Shakespeare uses Caliban's penultimate scene, the 'anti-masque' scene, to transform the genre, an idea borrowed, twisted and parodied from his rival playwrights. Benson's portrayal as "a kind of man-monkey" alike to the "low-browed, defiant" Caliban illustrated by Alfred Kubin (1918). In Messina's production, Prospero (Sir Michael Horden) brandishes a staff giving a dignified status also magically symbolic, whereas Jarman reflects Prospero's (Heathcote Williams) dominance effectively with Prospero stamping on Caliban's hand after dragging him inside. Although Jarman's production is marred with a lack of lighting, obscuring facial features and details, it furthers the idea of Prospero's dark magic, more importantly reflects Caliban's dark, manipulative and cunning nature evident as he influences the drunkards into undertaking his desires; "batter his skull, or paunch him with a stake. Caliban's naivety is furthered in act 2:2 by Trinculo and Stephano's entrance; Caliban has never seen outsiders before making way for a comic scene. Similarly Clarke's Caliban grovels, begging forgiveness, "how fine my master is", declaring his stupidity for "taking this drunkard as a god", genuinely afraid Prospero will "chastise" him. However, Greenaway's Caliban can only display his emotion through the speed and frenzy with which he moves which detracts from dramatic introduction. Jack Birkett plays Derrick Jarman's rather deluded, hunchbacked Caliban, which Lanier explains as Jarman's intention to "disrupt the play's status as an icon of straight high culture" by implanting "camp" and "transgressive sexualities", in his 1980 film 'The Tempest'. It is believed an incubus and a witch, Sycorax, begot Caliban thus his illegitimacy would bar him from succession. In direct contrast, Messina's 'text-faithful' production sees an ape-like Caliban, Warren Clarke, with a full body of hair, possibly based on F. Prospero's authority is also reflected through witty language and his superior knowledge, the ironic curse " Hag-seed" whilst humorous and insulting, is the truth, Sycorax was a witch.
Common topics in this essay:
Heathcote Williams,
Stephano Trinculo,
Henry Fuseli's,
Clarke's Caliban,
Trinculo Stephano,
Robert Cruikshank,
Shakespeare Caliban's,
Caliban Despite,
,
Prospero Miranda,
messina's production,
'prospero's books',
close facial shots,
prospero sir,
close facial,
act 12,
jarman's version,
inset frames,
greenaway's production,
facial shots,
stephano trinculo,
|
Acceptance Essays
