It Used to be green once vs. revenge gardening
The short stories It Used to Be Green Once by Patricia Grace and Revenge Gardening by Sue Harper have many differences. The children are all ashamed of their mother because of how she acts and the car she drives in the beginning of the first story while in the beginning of the second the child is very proud of his mother and her garden. How well the children listen to their mothers is very different between the two, because in the first the children always obey the mother even when they don't want to while in the second the boy disobeys his mother several times. Finally each story has a very different ending, in the first the family wins the lottery and they all live happily ever after and in the second the mother eventually loses the gardening battle to the neighbors. Both stories while they contain similar main characters have many differences.In It Used to Be Green Once the children at the start were very ashamed and embarrassed of their mother. This is shown when they try to keep her from doing the shopping because they don't want her to be seen in public, and whine about the swimming suits that she makes them wear. Finally wh
The mother in It Used to Be Green Once is a very powerful lady that always gets obedience from her children whether they like it or not. In both stories the view of the mother changes from start to finish either improving or not. Especially the mom is happy because she gets to buy a brand new car to replace her rusted, topless, old one. Obviously both mothers have a different type of respect because while fourteen children all obey their mothers' orders in the first story the only child Matt disobeys his mother several times in the second story. Both have totally different endings one leaving you felling happy and satisfied and the other leaving you upset, frustrated and generally unsatisfied. At the end of It Used to Be Green Once the family wins the lottery and they can afford to buy a lot of the things that they have always wanted. It is evident he is proud by the detail in which the colours and flowers in the garden are described as being bright and beautiful. This is a sad ending because the mother even though she has a bad attitude still does not deserve to have her garden ruined and the neighbors who have been nice all along should not have been practically forced to move away. Eventually he sneaks out of his house and assists them with planting the tree that ruins his mother's garden. The endings are not the same and leave you feeling completely different after reading each one. Matt, the main character in Revenge Gardening starts off being very proud of his mother because she is an excellent gardener. Even when she made her child wear a swim suit that was much too big for her the child still obeyed because she knew otherwise there would be worse to come. The mothers are looked up to very differently in each however, being respected like a drill sergeant in one and having their child sneak out and betray them in the other. The ending in Revenge Gardening is quite different because it is not happy at all.
Common topics in this essay:
Revenge Gardening,
Sue Harper,
Gardening Matt,
revenge gardening,
,
proud mother,
similar main characters,
family wins,
disobeys mother times,
family wins lottery,
neighbors stories,
children obey,
disobeys mother,
wins lottery,
story green,
similar main,
main characters,
|
Acceptance Essays
