Same story, two characters?
These days, there are very different ways off acquiring knowledge. Films, books, revues, magazines, movies, etc. Surprisingly enough, most of the films our days are take from books. They are modernized and cut down the most important parts.If we compare the film “Igby goes down” with J.D Salinger’s “The Catcher in the Rye”, we might find the characters of one represented as similar yet different in the other one. At closer comparison, one can see that many characters are similar, even though the different character traits of one figure in the novel might each be represented by a single figure in the film but, the resemblance is nonetheless still very noticeable. Holden is represented mostly by Igby. For example, in the novel, Holden has the tendency of lying in many different circumstances, just like Igby in the film. Another factor that appears in both, the novel and the film, is that both, Igby and Holden had been abused in one way or the other. Holden has been abused many times by teachers from school. Holden says so himself after the awkward experience he had at Mr. Antolini’s place, on page 193: . . .
Igby too was freed, he took the train and left toward California to see his dad, he left all his worries behind and left. She claims several times throughout the film to be Igby’s best friends, and to always be there for him, yet she leaves him for Oliver. Holden on his side lost his brother Allie. It happened the first time, when he walked in on him and Rachel, and saw his godfather, sitting there, his legs wide open and his pants down. That kind of stuff’s happened to me about twenty times since I was a kid. … Holden let all the emotions that he had held in for all that time out. Suki is represented by Jane, the innocent young girl. To name another resemblance between Holden and Igby, one could name the loss of a close one, the loss of a Hero figure. It is like a breakthrough, he finally is free. Salinger’s novel, Holden sits in the rain and lets himself to be drenched by the rain, instead of taking shelter under the roof of the carousel.
Common topics in this essay:
Igby Holden, Holden Igby, JD Salingers, Catcher Rye, , Oliver Holden, Jane Holden, Oliver Suki, film igby, Oliver Stradlaters, igby holden, jd salingers, film igby goes, suki represented, novel holden, novel film, salingers novel, holden igby, oliver suki, jd salingers novel, novel film igby, igby feel, |
Acceptance Essays
