lying arguments
Socrates is a man of great controversy. He has been portrayed as many different personalities such as a sophist to a great philosopher to just a vocal old man. The true nature of Socrates is to be questioned. He spoke his thoughts on life and what his philosophy on life was. A couple arguments that he spoke about really stood out about lying. These arguments had brute force and were made very clear through his dialogue. According to his dialogue, he felt that there were two different types of lies. The first type called the true lie, in Socrates mind feels, as this type is impossible. The true lie consists of one simply not telling the truth, as they know it. Socrates says:When a man in speech makes a bad representation of whatgods and heroes are like, just as a painter paints somethingthat doesn't resemble the things whose likeness he wishedAs can clearly be seen in this sentence, Socrates is pointing out a painter that knows that truth about what he is painting but is making it look different than he knows it as. The painter is doing this to portray something other than the truth to other people because the truth may either hurt him or hurt others. It is more of a protectio
My feelings towards lying are very close to the way Socrates feels. Socrates states through his words: For the lie in speech is a kind of imitation of the affections in the soul, a phantom of it that comes into being after it, and not quite an unadulterated lie. An example of doing something like this would be a hostage situation. There are trust factors involved there, but sometimes it is necessary to lie I that field. He is not a big fan towards immoral words and his dialogue proves his point well. (382b)Socrates believes that this is like a front for not knowing the answer to a question. He was describing how people would tell their children of stories in the past. I hold some high values in the area of lying. He thinks: Don't you know, that all gods and human beings hate the true lie, if that expression can be used. With the true lie, I feel you are lying to yourself because you know the truth. It could be a made up lie from one person not knowing the truth and making a story up to look good in front of others. Something that is unknown to you, but you feel that you still must give an explanation instead of feeling naive. Socrates believes the second type of lie is called a lie in speech. He also feels lies in speech are told as a substitute for knowledge not known.
Common topics in this essay:
Arguments Socrates,
Republic Plato,
true lie,
lie speech,
truth socrates,
lying arguments,
don't truth,
382b socrates,
socrates believes,
knowing truth,
truth don't,
type lie,
|
Acceptance Essays
