Life is the most wonderful gift that God gives us. He also gives
us the power to do what we wish with that life. We can keep it and guard
it, or we can take it away. It follows that murder is the worst crime
anyone could ever commit. It is a crime that no one can ever make right
because once you take a life away you can never give it back. Penalties
exacted from criminals are made to fit the crimes committed. The worst
crime possible should therefore receive the worst penalty possible. That
Take, for example, the case of a man who is caught shoplifting.
He does not deserve the same punishment as someone who is convicted of
assault and battery. Most people would have no problem agreeing with
this. Yet many of these same people believe that a cold blooded killer
deserves the same life sentence as a convicted kidnapper who did not kill
his prisoner. Granted these are both serious offenses, but our system of
law works by degrees of seriousness (Bedau, p.326). The mental damage done
to that prisoner can be turned around, but the life taken away by the murderer can
never be given back. They should therefore be given a harsher punishment
than life in prison. In terms of justice, we should all get what we deserve.
One argument against the death penalty is that the bible tells us
not to murder. If this includes all people it should include the
government. However, the death penalty is not quite the same as murder.
It is an exacting of justice. Consequently, the Bible also says, an eye
for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. It could also say a life for a life as
well. The government also has rights that we as citizens do not have. As
Mayor Ed Koch says in his essay on the death penalty, the execution of a
lawfully condemned killer is no more an act of murder than is legal
imprisonment an act of kidnapping. (Bedau, p.318)
...