DECARTES
The existence of God has been a question since the idea of God was even conceived. Rene Descartes tries to prove God's existence, and to show that there is without a doubt something external to one's own existence. Decartes is looking for a definite certainty, a foundation for which he can base all of his beliefs and know that they are, indeed, true. Descartes' overall project is to find a definite certainty on which he can base all his knowledge and beliefs, including the existence of God.One might infer that Descartes is a "non-believer" in the existence of a heavenly being, a God that presides over humans and gives us faith. However, this is simply not the case. Descartes focus is on trying to destroy all of the uncertainties that have come about by the attempted scientific explanations of such a supreme being or God. For Descartes, and all of the other believers in the world, the existence of God provides a convenient answer to unexplained questions, while never providing answers to the questions about God himself. This is evidenced a great deal in the circular argument made by Descartes in the Meditations. What follows, is a brief account of the third meditation i
Basically, it's like using a word in it's own definition, or 'the definition of an apple is an apple. In other words, the mind generates thoughts and ideas about a physical form, and develops a reality for this form, through previous schema and beliefs. In my mind, Descartes exceeded in many parts of his argument, but failed to prove from a logical standpoint the existence of a higher being. However, according to Descartes, since it has an objective reality, it must follow that it also must have a formal reality as well. To understand that to have an idea is to exist is one case, but take for instance the man whom can think, just as someone thinks of God, of a being so absolutely imperfect, clearly and distinctly, that it does not exist. " The only problem with Descartes' (unsound in my opinion) argument is when the existence of God arises as a notion, for there is no form of idea for the notion of God to originate from. ' The argument begins to get a little bit ambiguous when he begins discussing the uncertainty of his beliefs. " Descartes provides us with the idea that an object will have an effect when it stems from a legitimate cause, or an initial idea that precedes with equal or superior properties in one's intellect. n which shows Descartes' response to the question, "What is God?" Can one perceive or confirm the existence of an idea that is external to him, an idea such as God? In order to determine the answer we must start by understanding the ways in which we can conclude an objects' existence. This is the type of circular definition that Descartes is trying to avoid at all costs. Ultimately, it is his own dependence on another being that proves to him that there is a God. Is it possible, then, to create the idea of a finite being from an infinite existence, outside of the physical and mental, in a state all of it's own? Descartes' argument quickly answers that the response would be that a finite being cannot completely, if at all, comprehend the ideas that would cause God to exist, and therefore the basis for doubt is lost in an intangible proof. Descartes explains three ways in which a person might come to such a conclusion - the first, through nature; the second, through feeling a value that is independent of the will of the object; and the third, the objective reality of an idea, or the "cause and effect profile. This belief stems from the theory that if a man is independent from all other existence and ideas about forms and matter, then he has the ability to become infinite. Additionally, the mere fact that he believes that there is a God provides yet another piece of proof towards His existence.
Common topics in this essay:
Descartes God,
Descartes Meditations,
Rene Descartes,
God Descartes,
Meditation III,
existence god,
it's own,
objective reality,
according descartes,
idea god,
god's existence,
idea cause,
own existence,
independent existence,
god provides,
|
Acceptance Essays
