who is to judge
Charles Murray writes in his essay "The Coming White Underclass" about the increasing population of illegitimacy of the white social class. Murray insists that illegitimacy is the largest problem in society with out any exceptions. Murray examines many possibilities for the rise in pregnancies such as ethics, social justifications and social engineering. He uses cold hard facts to start off the essay but as they fall apart so does his essay. Murray's essay hits a mid way point and becomes merely opinion, and his opinions are controversial in my eyes. I plan to refute his ideas of solving illegitimacy and show that not only are they unethical but unacceptable in the social and government aspects of life. "To have a baby that you cannot care for yourself is profoundly irresponsible, and the government will no longer subsidize it."(Murray84)This summarizes the main point and opinion of Charles Murray's essay. Murray's opinions seem to conflict with what is being done and what should be done. Murray's opinions express economic setbacks, and family ethics such as if you can not find a job then how are you going to teach your child responsibilities if you don't have the responsibilities to find a job. He enlight
Where are single mothers to look for money? According to Murray the answer is simple "If she wants to keep a child, she must enlist suppor!t from her parents, boyfriend, siblings, neighbors, church, or philanthropies"(84). Not only are they (government) going to have to pay to keep the orphanage open but also they will have to pay some one to run it. He believes that single mothers should be forced to marry or pay the prices, as did the main character of The Scarlet Letter. Murray focuses on two points, what the government could do and ethics. He doesn't trust the single mother enough to raise her own child; he automatically assumes that she will need help. Single mothers are not eligible for subsidies houses or for food stamps"(84). How do you know that any one is going to give their money to you and your child? Suppose your family, boyfriend and anyone else of close relation plus the government disowns you, what are you to do? Murray has three steps, that I view as controversial, to overcome support from government affiliations. However, he begins to discriminate against single mothers. Charles Murray uses the "old-fashion" way of thought by saying that if a married couple raises a child the child's roots will be stronger and it will be a better person. "Second, the need to self-selection process. Murray's lacking ability will come back to hurt him in the future. "One of the few concrete things that the government can do to increase the rewards of marriage is make the tax code favor marriage and children"(85). There are laws already on the books about the right of the stare to take a child from a neglectful mother" (84). Murray should look into how much the government spends on other countries and their homeless before he nominates illegitimate children to be sacrificed.
Common topics in this essay:
According Murray,
Charles Murray,
Letter Stigma,
White Underclass,
Charles Murray's,
Scarlet Letter,
United America,
Dependent Children,
single mother,
single mothers,
Instead Murray,
charles murray,
scarlet letter,
child stayed single,
money government,
murray suggests,
government pay,
support government,
pay orphanage,
stayed single mother,
murray's essay,
raise own child,
single mother raise,
|
Acceptance Essays
