The attitudes which Wordsworth and Shelley express towards Nature in "Mont Blanc" and "Tintern Abbey" are both ones of admiration and appreciation at nature's power, beauty, and majesty. But, they have very different descriptions and views of nature and how mankind should treat it, and react to it. According to Shelley, nature is both resplendent and deadly; a dynamic force that cannot be tamed by man. While appreciating nature's aesthetic majesty, Shelley warns man not to equate beauty with tranquility. In "Tintern Abbey" rather than placing man and nature in opposition, Wordsworth views them as complementary elements of a whole, recognizing man as a part of nature.
"Tintern Abbey" and "Mont Blanc" both view nature as a sublime, and majestic thing. It is deeply respected by both Wordsworth and Shelley yet in different ways. Both poems describe a particular natural scene. In "Tintern Abbey", Wordsworth describes a "green pastoral landscape", where in "Mont Blanc", Shelley describes the icy glacial capped peaks of the Swiss Alps. Both poets seem to hold a great appreciation and respect for nature and the things that they are surrounded by, but each view nature in a different respect with regard to humanity.
. . .
In "Tintern Abbey", Wordsworth is also speaking to his sister Dorothy instead of to the landscape. Shelley, however, focuses on a "dizzy ravine" whose grandeur puts him in a trance, not at all a comforting force, but a force not to be reckoned with. The setting of each poem has to do a great deal with each poet's opinion of the relationship of nature to the human world. depicted in Shelley's poem is much more untamed and cruel than in Wordsworth's. While appreciating nature's aesthetic majesty, Shelley warns man not to equate beauty with tranquility. 122-123) He shows nature to be a gentle, nurturing force that teaches and soothes humanity. He warns the human world not to take beauty as serenity or placidity, but to respect the power that nature holds. On the other hand "Plots of cottage ground" (ll. He says this was similar to how he reacted to the natural setting around him in his adolescence, though at this stage in his life Wordsworth seems to experience a more emotional response filled with passion and "aching joys". 12-15)
In "Mont Blanc", Shelley portrays nature as a mighty and powerful entity that feels utter indifference for man.
The attitudes toward nature and its relationship to the human world expressed by both Wordsworth and Shelley are both complementary and contrasting. Shelley views it as something to be seen and appreciated but not to be fooled with.
Approximate Word count =
1102
Approximate Pages =
4 (250 words per page double spaced)
Simply subscribe to view this paper, and 100,000 others.
| CREDIT CARD |
ONLINE CHECK |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
JOIN BY PHONE
|
|
|