Revolution
A revolution can be defined as an extensive or drastic change in conditions. Although from contrasting times and perspectives, two authors who encounter the topic of revolution in their writings are Karl Marx and Thomas Kuhn. In The Structure of scientific Revolutions, Kuhn discusses a wide range of changes in the scientific understandings of nature, while in The 18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, Marx focuses on the French Revolution of 1848. At first glance it may seem that scientific and political revolutions have little in common, but upon closer examination it is revealed that these two different types of revolutions share numerous characteristics. In fact, it can be concluded that Marx's theory of political revolution confirms Kuhn's theory of scientific revolution.In his writing, Marx explains his ideas on revolution to the background of the French Revolution of 1848. According to Marx, history plays the key role in revolutions. He demonstrates this belief when he states, And just when they seemed engaged in revolutionizing themselves and things, in creating something that has never existed, precisely in such periods of revolutionary crisis they anxiously conjure up the spirits of the past to their service and borrow
In conclusion, Marx's theory of revolution does indeed confirm Kuhn's theory of scientific revolution. In the case of the bourgeois revolution "normal science" proves able to handle the crisis provoking problem and all returns to "normal. (Kuhn 13-14) In order for a revolution to occur, a paradigm must be proven wrong. " This type of transformation is not a true revolution. " Although ecstasy may not be the everyday spirit, there are certainly fewer obstacles to overcome than if a new paradigm had to be accepted. Then again, no real change has occurred. The authors were men of contrasting times and places. Likewise, in Marx, the knowledge of the mother tongue never leaves, even though you do not use it anymore. An example of this can be found where Kuhn writes about the electricity paradigm: The history of electrical research in the first half of the eighteenth century provides a more concrete and better known example of the way a science develops before it acquires its first universally received paradigm. He remarks "normal science means research firmly based upon one or more past scientific achievements that some particular scientific community acknowledges for a time as supplying the foundation for its further practice. (Marx 303)The proletariat revolution starts out like the bourgeois revolution. When there is a paradigm shift in a scientific revolution, the old paradigm is discredited, and in a sense history. However, "normal science fails to explain the anomaly, and the crisis persists. However, the ideas of Kuhn's paradigm shifts run parallel to Marx's thoughts on political revolution. On the other hand, there is the proletariat revolution, which Marx describes as:Like those of the nineteenth century, criticizing themselves constantly, interrupting themselves continually in their own course, come back to the apparently accomplished in order to begin afresh, deride with unmerciful thoroughness the inadequacies, weaknesses, and paltriness of their first attempts, seem to throw down their adversary only in order that he may draw new strength from the earth and rise again, more gigantic, before them, recoil ever and anon from the indefinite prodigiousness of their own aims, until a situation has been created which makes all turning back impossible.
Common topics in this essay:
According Kuhn,
Thomas Kuhn's,
Referring Marx,
According Marx,
Watson Franklin,
French Revolution,
Karl Marx's,
Karl Marx,
,
Comparable Marx,
scientific revolution,
bourgeois revolution,
normal science,
political revolutions,
theory scientific revolution,
scientific revolutions,
marx's theory,
kuhn's theory,
theory scientific,
proletariat revolution,
kuhn's theory scientific,
marx's theory political,
ecstasy everyday,
french revolution 1848,
ecstasy everyday spirit,
|
Acceptance Essays
