Subjects:
The two poems I am comparing are "Joining The Colours" by Katherine Tynan and "The Send Off" by Wilfred Owen. " Joining The Colours" is about a regiment of soldiers leaving Dublin in August 1914 to go to France to fight. This was at the beginning of the First World War and all the soldiers were happy because it was an opportunity for them to show their girlfriends and their families that they were brave. "The Send Off" is about a regiment of young soldiers who are departing later in the war. This poem was written a few years after "Joining The Colours". The mood of each occasion is different because "Joining The Colours" was written when the soldiers and their relative's thought that the war would be over by Christmas but instead it finished much later on and millions of soldiers got killed. The mood in "The Send Off" is totally different because the soldiers were already afraid. They knew how dangerous the war was because of what so many people had experienced since "Joining The Colours" was written in 1914. There was no celebration for them because most of the people knew what was going to happen. The stru
. . .
The first stanza starts in a serious mood "Down the close darkening lanes they sang their way". This is because the poet is trying to convince the reader that war is the most terrible thing that ever happened.
Both of the poems are similar in being about soldiers going to war. This shows that they are afraid because everything is so quiet that it looks like a secret mission. An important difference is that "Joining the Colours" was written by a person who had no experience about war and "The Send Off" was written by Wilfred Owen who was a front line soldier and knew how bad it was from his own experience. The poet knows that hardly any will return and when they do, they will come back to silence, sadness and broken hopes. Even though there are some words which convey an image that war is bad, most of the style of writing is positive and even happy. The style of writing throughout the poem is sad and conveys an image that war is completely bad. "The Send Off" is a sadder poem because there was no-one to celebrate and nothing to celebrate for the soldiers and there were no relatives saying goodbye. When the soldiers are going off to war they are trying to be brave by singing but they are very afraid "so secretly, like wrong hushed-up they went". One reason why there was no celebration for the soldiers was because they were not local to the area. The soldiers are making many different noises "with tin whistles, mouth-organs". An other difference is that "Joining The Colours" was written at the beginning of the First World War and everyone was happy, there was a lot of celebration and most of the soldier's relatives were there watching them.
Essay's Topics
All research is for reference purposes only.