Did the Soldiers Themselves Give a More Accurate
In this essay I will be comparing official accounts, soldiers accounts, paintings, poems, and textbook sources based on trench warfare. Section A is a series of textbook sources and I will be comparing these to sources in Sections B, C, and D. I will be also comparing these sources to a video that e watched in class. Whilst I compare the sources I will be considering the reliability, accuracy, validity, and the source of every different account. To find out how accurate each source is I will be discussing the provenance, content, other sources and my own knowledge. I have taken into mind that the historians and soldiers will have different views to one another. Most information in the form of paintings and photo's would have probably been censored. All of the soldier's accounts would have been from memory and might not be as reliable as the textbook sources that are very reliable because they are secondary evidence. I will also have to consider the time that the source was taken or recorded, the location and weather the writer had a motive or not. Depending on the position that the soldiers were will make some sources less reliable. This is because one source could say that the soldiers were in a good condition and one could sa
5 million soldiers died of disease and sickness in the 4 war years. This was probably used to show Anglo German relations in the trenches and to turn people at home against the even more. B6 is a list of army rations that a man was suppose to receive each day. However my own knowledge supports the reliability of the source. This first thing that I must comment on is has this source been made up top try and influence the minds of people at home. The artist, Henry tonks however was sent to the front line as an official war artist so there is a good chance that the government would have told his to hide the overall impact that trench life was having on the soldiers. None of my own knowledge hasn't been commented on in the sources and almost all of the information given by the soldiers was commented on in the video and in the resource book. But is this source reliable? First one soldier is standing up it the trench and I know that if you did you had a Very good chance that you would have been killed by one of the German snipers. However there are numerous sources in Section A that make me consider the reliability of this source. Also there is only one other source that it links with ands that is an official photograph so the reliability is doubted again. I will be using section A, which are textbook sources as the basis to test the reliability of the official accounts and soldiers accounts. Both of the photos that I have commented on have been supported by other sources in Section A however some information on there has not been supported. This source quotes "or by burning it with a candle or lighted cigarette end" so we do know that soldiers in the trenches did actually have cigarettes. Grittith who fought on the western front writes source C6 and talks about the duties that soldiers went thorough. This source is also supported by my own knowledge because I know that the trenches were filled with rats and when conscription was introduced that some people said that they were terrified of rats so they couldn't go to war.
Common topics in this essay:
,
Henry Tonks,
Source B4,
A4 C1,
Golden Dawn,
B4 C4,
A5 C2,
Recruiting Advertisement,
Source A5,
Wilfred Owen,
own knowledge,
official accounts,
front line,
sources section,
trenches source,
source supported,
people home,
reliability source,
textbook sources,
source a5,
july 1st 1916,
people home source,
supported sources section,
source supported sources,
source a4 comments,
|
Acceptance Essays
