Second hand smoke
The article, Secondhand Smoke, by Steve Milloy, claims that secondhand smoke is not the primary link to heart attacks. Milloy analyzed a previous study performed in Helena, Montana. This study suggested strongly that secondhand smoke was the reason heart attack numbers were high. A non-smoking ban was placed in all public facilities throughout the town. The researchers noticed a drastic decline in the rate of heart attacks, and quickly drew the conclusion that the non-smoking ban was to thank. Overall, Milloy argues that research was poorly conducted and all variables were not properly monitored. Milloy supports his claim by discovering the results wer
According to Milloy, there was a very similiar decline in heart attack rates in 1998, four years earlier, with no definite explanation why. Also, he says that the study was not available to the public six months after the presentation was presented. By the previous statement, it is implied that the research, according to him, was poorly analyzed. Many necessary factors (ie: age, weight, smoker or non) were not included in the data. Overall, this is a very well written article regarding the non-smoking ban placed in Helena, Montana. e issued at a "via quick-and-dirty slideshow presentation" at the American College of Cardiology. One weakness is the tone in selective statements. There was no concrete medical evidence that would prove whether or not the smoking ban had an effect on citizens of Helena, Montana. The author suggests that if a "miracle" could happen four years prior to the study, why couldn't it happen again? He states that "if whatever causes the 1998 dip happened again in 2002, the Miracle of Helena is really the Mirage of Helena. " Also, Milloy finds out that there was no study done on any pre- or post-ban patients. There are very few weaknesses in his argument. Also, there are a few occassions where the author makes sarcastic remarks. Milloy, in addition, says that the persons' lifestyles and environmental factors also would have an effect in the risk of heart attacks and would not be directly linked to secondhand smoke. Milloy also states that if the information that the study provided is accurate, then there was a drop in heart attack rates.
Common topics in this essay:
College Cardiology,
Helena Montana,
Doctor Glantz,
Montana Milloy,
According Milloy,
Overall Milloy,
Helena Milloy,
Steve Milloy,
secondhand smoke,
non-smoking ban,
heart attacks,
heart attack,
helena montana,
,
non-smoking ban placed,
doctor glantz,
supports claim,
ban placed,
results issued,
milloy supports,
milloy supports claim,
heart attack rates,
|
Acceptance Essays
