Why does Socrates think that justice cannot be "Paying back

             Why does Socrates think that justice cannot be "Paying back your debts" if justice is conceived as a craft?
             In Book One of Plato's Republic, Socrates thinks that justice cannot be "paying back your debts" if justice is conceived as a craft. Socrates believes that a craft "is a disciplined body of knowledge founded on a grasp of the truth about what is good and bad, right and wrong, in the matters of concern to it." (Plato Republic p.977 footnote.6¬). Crafts are only capable of doing one thing, for instance: medicine is a craft by giving needs to the body, cooking is a craft by preparing food, and music is the craft of entertaining by playing a musical instrument. If justice is considered as a craft, meaning that it is parallel to the craft of medicine, the craft of cooking and the craft of music, with the purpose of concerning only about its own matters. With this purpose Socrates declares that justice cannot be paying one's debts. Paying one's debts is paying back what is owed, " it is just to give to each what is owed to him" (Plato. Republic Book I, p.976 fragment 331e). The understanding of paying back what is owed leads us to two actions either bad or good. If someone does evil to you, according to the understanding of justice as "paying one's debts", you would pay back the same way as you were treated. The same will apply if someone does something good to you and your respond will be a fruitful one, therefore agreeing with Socrates understanding of craft. Justice of "paying one's debts" cannot be considered a craft because justice as any other craft does not go both ways, it only goes one, either good or bad.
             ...

More Essays:

APA     MLA     Chicago
Why does Socrates think that justice cannot be "Paying back. (2000, January 01). In MegaEssays.com. Retrieved 22:47, November 21, 2026, from https://www.megaessays.com/viewpaper/10593.html