There is little doubt that the terror attacks of September 11, 2001
            
 have had economic impact both in the United States and in the other
            
 industrialized nations of the globe.  The question is, however, how much
            
 impact, and, if there has been significant impact, in what areas'  More
            
 importantly, however, the question might profitably asked: how can one
            
 determine whether the economic conditions obtaining in the industrialized
            
 world are a result of 9/11 or of other forces pre-existing or co-existing
            
 with the terror attacks and subsequent Bush agenda for coping with the
            
       Indeed, it appears, after a brief review of recent literature
            
 concerning economics in a post-9/11 global setting, that the attacks had
            
 relatively little to do with direct economic effects and, at best, are a
            
 component of an economic two-step that has resulted in global soft
            
 economies.  The President's 2003 Economic Report also glosses over the
            
 direct effects of 9/11, offering what appear to be relatively
            
 unsubstantiated claims about economic factors, none of which are firmly
            
 linked in the report to any bona fide research; indeed, if the President's
            
 Economic Report were a research paper, the author would fail.
            
       For example, the President's report contends that the reason home
            
 refinancing was such a major component of lending in the preceding period
            
 was that interest rates were low, and that, therefore, the homeowners
            
 refinanced in order to spend money; home improvements are mentioned.
            
 Another trend mentioned was the "cash out" boom, in which homeowners
            
 refinanced to take virtually all the equity out of their homes for other
            
 purposes, more even than had been the case with conventional home equity
            
 loans. (President's Report 2003 p. 33)
            
       The report noted that "According to the Federal Home Loan Mortgage
            
 Corporation (Freddie Mac), holders of conventional, conforming mortgages
            
 liquefied about $59 billion in...