Explain the Main Difference Between....
A-Bentham and Mill's Understanding of Utilitarianism
Jeremy Bentham dismissed appeal to the Bible, conscience or Natural Law as empty and meaningless. He was a radical empiricist, believing that knowledge had to come from the senses, he also thought it was possible to provide a single scientifically objective standard of morality (The Principle of Utility). Bentham thought human beings should classify and measure any action in terms of how many units of pain or pleasure it will produce. Bentham was a hedonist; he believed that pleasure was the only good and pain the only evil. He devised a Hedonic Calculus, by which he thought it possible to compare quantitatively pleasure and pain. He would ask seven questions to determine the value of pleasure, they were:-
1. Duration – How long it lasts
2. Intensity – How intense it is
3. Propinquity – How near it is
4. Extent – How widely it covers
5. Certainty – How sure we are that it will come
6. Purity – How free from pain it is
7. Fecundity – How much it will lead to more pleasure
"Nature has placed mankind under the governments of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do, as well as to determine what we shall do"
John Stuart Mill like Bentham was a hedonist, however he rejected Bentham's quantitative assessment of pleasure and replaces it with a qualitative one. He regarded intellectual pleasures as qualitatively superior to physical ones, arguing that the pleasures of the intellect, the imagination and a clear conscience are more valuable and desirable than human beings' animal nature. Mill thought that be dividing pleasure into higher and lower orders. Higher order pleasures were intellectual pleasures; lower orders were bodily pleasure.
"It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisf...